Whitney or Elton? Your thoughts please!

Can you help with a recent (slightly boozy!) holiday argument please - who had 3 more iconic songs, Whitney Houston or Elton John??

I went with Whitney and:

I will always love you

I wanna dance with somebody

and

The greatest love of all

(Bobby Brown might disagree - but that's his prerogative. Sorry!)

Over to you now! 

8093744864?profile=RESIZE_400x

 

You need to be a member of ABN Community to add comments!

Join ABN Community

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Steward's Inquiry: Strictly speaking, 'I Will Always Love You' is a Dolly song and 'The Greatest Love Of All' was a hit first for George Benson....and because of that, it's gotta be Elt, (even though Bernie writes a lot of the words, Elton always composes the music). :-)

    Your Song. Tiny Dancer. Saturday Night's Alright For Fighting. 

    And he can keep his Oscar winning songs in reserve!

    • Damn. I wasn't losing too badly until some pesky DJ started getting involved.....

      • Ha! Sorry! Occupational Hazard. 

         

  • I'm going with the Whitney lovers!

    I Wanna Dance with Somebody, One Moment in Time and Greatest Love, I can belt them all out as long as no-ones listening of course!

    Got to say though, is Goodbye Yellow Brick Road not one of Elton's iconic songs, it's one of my favourites!

     

  • Team Elton here too!! 

     

    • Oooo and I'd go with Tiny Dancer, Rocket man and Your Song! 

  • :-D I didn't realise it was an argument!  Still going with Elton.  And thank you Jeanette Lowe those were the three songs I listed too!

  • Not a fan of either but I'd go with Elton. Rocketman. I'm still standing and Candle in the Wind. 

  • Going for Elton John here

     - I'm still standing

    - Dont go breaking my heart

    - Rocket man

    (might have went with Candle in the wind, or Circle of life for 'iconic' given the princess Di and Disney links respectively - but never liked either song)

  • I would go with Reginald Kenneth Dwight.....

    Top three

    Rocket Man, Saturday Night's Alright for Fighting & Candle in the wind

This reply was deleted.